Case Study

A case study demonstrates how the many parts of your organisation interact. They bring more attention to a challenge and demonstrate the advantages of the adopted solution. They may also contribute to more extensive research. Other theories and approaches may come to light as you investigate and evaluate new concepts. You may improve your tactics and raise the value you offer by using this new information. Case studies are excellent resources that can demonstrate not only how inventive, successful, and skilled your business and teams have become, but also how trends have developed among your clients and services.

Khulla

Khulla Case Study

Synopsis

Hina (53) and Sohaib (55) have been married for 35 years and have three children together who are living independently. They live in a three bedroom apartment in Karachi. Sohaib works full-time as a business analyst for a bank. Sohaib is alcoholic. Hina works full-time as a Personal Secretary in a company. Hina is tired of his alcoholic problem.

Problem

Over the last few years, Sohaib and Hina have grown apart and have spent less time together, with Sohaib travelling for his work and Hina regularly for events with her boss. Two months ago, Sohaib returned home from work drunk, and started to beat Hina . She was bruised and seriously injured. She was hospitalized for a day.

Solution

Hina approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for her Khulla case.

  • Hina was entitled to a complete medical coverage from Sohaib.
  • Hina was entitled 50% of the housing and spousal maintenance.
  • She got khulla.

Inheritance Case Study

Synopsis

The case study involved a client who had become subject to freezing order over property assets and funds transferred into bank accounts from a spouse.

Problems

The spouse died and his family pursued these assets and funds alleging undue influence of the client over an elderly partner who the family alleged had been viciously taken advantage of. The amounts that had been given went into multi millions and the action had been handled by a several lawyers.

Solution

After three years of the action proceeding, the client sought Shabana Ali & Associates help and assistance and having reviewed the issues and noted the parties were still only dealing with disclosure. We held discussions with the claimants lawyers and advised that a counterclaim for substantial losses would now be brought if the claim was not dropped. We were pleased the claimants then sought to compromise. The recovery of all assets and wealth was completed within 6 months of our involvement.

Inheritance
Mediation

Mediation Case Study

Synopsis

Ms. Serish and Faisal have been married for 10 years and have two children living in a joint family. Faisal running his small business and Serish is house wife.

Problem

When Faisal returned home from work and often Serish complains about other family members one day her father took her into his house without permission of Faisal along with her minor daughter aged about 2 years. Faisal went to take her back along with his son aged about 7 years and 6 months but his father in law refused and informed they have filed a case for Khulla, Dowry Articles and maintenance and notice will served very soon, but Faisal wanted to continue his marriage. Faisal did not find any solution except to consult any lawyer, his friend informed about Shabana Ali & Associates and fix his appointment.

Solution

Faisal approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for her case settlement. Through mediation problem resolved and Case for Khulla, Dowry Articles and maintenance was withdrawn. Ms. Serish returned back into his husband’s house and living happily with her husband Mr. Faisal.

Ejectment of Tenant Case Study

Synopsis

Mr. Azhar gave his Apartment to Mr. Sarfaraz on rent in the year of 2013 and rent agreement signed for eleven months wherein rent decided Rs. 18,000/-. Mr. Azhar is a professor in a University and Mr. Sarfaraz doing job in a Private company. Mr. Sarfaraz is very bad in maintenance of apartment.

Problem

Mr. Sarfaraz did not renew tenancy agreement on several requests made by Mr. Azhar. Tenant is living on same rent and never increase and used to pay rent late and often made default in payment of rent and Mr. Azhar was very upset because of the attitude of tenant. Whenever Owner Mr. Azhar requested him to vacate his apartment he refuses to vacate the premises and stop paying rent as well.

Solution

In the year of 2019 Mr. Azhar consult his case with Shabana Ali & Associates and appointed for his case of ejectment of tenant.

  • Rent was recovered.
  • Tenant vacate the premises.
Ejectment of Tenant
Defamation

Defamation Case Study

Synopsis

Dr. Khan was studying MBBS and her parents fixed her marriage with Mr. Ahsan. Rukhsati was taken place after 2 years of Nikkhah. Husband and wife relationship was not maintained by Mr. Ahsan and taken plea that he had to go to back on his job immediately and when she come to Dubai then will do. It was decided that after marriage Dr. Khan will live in Dubai with her husband.

Problem

Mr. Ahsan returned to Dubai after few days of his marriage and whenever Dr. Khan asked about her visa Ahsan avoided and gave lame excuses. One day Khan ‘s in laws sent her into her parents’ house and when her family tried to talked with Ahsan and his family they were not responding at all and after few days Ahsan pronounced Divorce with the remarks of that she cannot be mother.

Solution

Parents of Dr. Khan approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for her case.

  • In-laws of Dr. Khan apology to Dr. Khan her parents in writing as well as apology published in leading newspapers.

Recovery of Dower Amount and Articles

Synopsis

Mrs. Zubeida Khan and Gulab Khan married together, dower was given at the time of marriage in the shape of gold (5 Tola) and they had three children one son and two daughters. Mr. Gulab Khan died in a blast at CNG Filling Station during work.

Problem

The father in law of Zubeida snatched her dower and kicked her along with her children from his house in three cloths and not allowing her to collect her belongings and dowry articles. She belongs to very poor family her parents tried to resolve this issue amicably, but all in vain.

Solution

The parents of Zubeida approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for her case.

  • Zubeida was entitled for her Dower amount.
  • Zubeida was entitled for her dowry articles and all other belongings.
Dowry
Guardianship Certificate

Guardianship Certificate

Synopsis

Khawar and Erum mutually decided for their separation. They have two children and the custody of children were with Mr. Khawar. Erum got second marriage.

Problem

Mr. Khawar wanted to take his children abroad on vocation, but visa authority required custody order / guardianship certificate for travelling purpose after separation.

Solution

Mr. Khawar discussed his case with Shabana Ali & Associates and appointed for his case to custody or guardianship certificate.

  • Mr. Khawar appointed Guardian of his children.
  • Mr. Khawar can take his children anywhere in the world without any hindrance.

2nd Guardianship Certificate Case Study

Synopsis

Ms. Aima and Mr. Ali Zafar mutually decided for their separation as well as custody of their children according to sharia. Children were living with Ms. Aima at the time of separation son till the age of 7 years and daughter till the age of puberty and thereafter children were living in the custody of Mr. Ali Zafar.

Problem

Ms. Aima applied for her immigration of Turkey as well as for her children, but the foreign authority / Turkey authority required court papers where should clearly mention joint custody / joint guardian of their children according to her case.

Solution

Ms. Aima and Mr. Ali Zafar approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for their case of joint custody.

  • Ms. Aima and Mr. Ali Zafar appointed joint Guardian of their children.
  • Children are in joint custody of Ms. Aima and Mr. Ali Zafar.
  • Ms. Aima and Mr. Ali Zafar can take their children anywhere in the world without any hindrance.
Joint Guardianship
Meeting with Children

Meeting with Children

Synopsis

Mr. Amir was working out of Pakistan and his wife was living with his family along with his children and suddenly his wife Zareen left the house of the parents of Mr. Amir and shifted into the house of her father and stopped meeting of children with their grandparents and other family members.

Problem

Mr. Amir returned back to Pakistan and went to his in-laws’ house to meet his wife and children, but the father of Zareen refused to enter into his house even not allowed him to meet his wife and children. Mr. Amir tried his best but his wife and father not allowed to meet and see his children.

Solution

Mr. Amir fixed his appointment with Shabana Ali & Associates and appointed to handle his case.

  • Mr. Amir entitled of meeting with his children being father have legal right.

Custody of Children Case Study

Synopsis

Mr. Umer and Aleena had three children aged about 10 years, 6 years and 1 year. Aleena was fed-up due to daily family disputes and left the house of her husband and shifted into her parents’ house.

Problem

Umer went to her parents’ house and snatched the children and directed his family members not to allow Aleena to take them even not allow to meet and see the children. Aleena and her family members requested many times but Umer and his family always insulted them. Aleena and her family members tried their best but they could not meet with children.

Solution

Aleena’s sister fixed her appointment with Shabana Ali & Associates and appointed to handle this case.

  • Court given custody of children to Ms. Aleena.
  • Directed Mr. Umer to go to guardian court if he has any claim regarding custody.
Custody of Children
Breach of Contract

Breach of Contract Case Study

Synopsis

Mr. Khursheed Ilyas purchased a commercial shop from Mr. Sarfaraz and signed a Sale agreement wherein clearly mentioned that Mr. Khursheed had given 50% of total Sale consideration and rest of the 50% of total sale consideration will pay before the registration / transfer of documents and promised to register sublease in the name of Mr. Khursheed immediately instead of registering in his name through the builder.

Problem

Mr. Sarfaraz registered sublease in the name of his wife whereas he promised to register into the name of Khursheed Ilyas and whenever Khursheed Ilyas requested him to transfer the title into his name Mr. Sarfaraz promised and when time comes he avoided. Khursheed was so upset and unable to understand why he is acting like this.

Solution

Mr. Khursheed approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for his case.

  • Khursheed deposited outstanding 50% of total Sale consideration in Court.
  • Court directed to register the documents into the name of Khursheed.

Recovery of Dower Amount, Maintenance and Divorce Deed

Synopsis

Bushra married with Hussain and Hussain is working in Dubai since few years. It was decided that after marriage Bushra will live in Dubai with her husband. Bushra completed her education just before her marriage. She wanted to go to Dubai to live with her husband.

Problem

Hussain returned to Dubai after few days of his marriage and whenever Bushra asked about her visa Hussain avoided and gave lame excuses. One day Bushra’s in laws sent her into her parents’ house and when her family tried to talked with Hussain and his family they were not responding at all and after few days Hussain pronounced Divorce with disgusting allegations.

Solution

Parents of Bushra approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for her case.

  • Bushra was entitled for her Dower amount.
  • Maintenance of Iddat period.
  • Divorce Deed with correction.
Recovery of Dower Amount, Maintenance and Divorce Deed
Fair Rent

Fair Rent

Synopsis

Mr. Ansar is the owner of a house and 15 years ago entered into a Tenancy Agreement with Mr. Saboor, rent was fixed Rs. 15,000/- per month and will increase 10% of rent on completion of every 11 month, but rent was not increased even tenancy agreement not renewed by the tenant.

Problem

Mr. Saboor (Tenant) enjoying facility of house located in a posh area of city Karachi but not increasing rent as decided at the time of Tenancy Agreement whereas the rent is very high in this locality and Mr. Ansar wanted to increase average rent according to locality or neighbourhood.

Solution

Mr. Ansar fixed his appointment with Shabana Ali & Associates and appointed to handle his case of Fair rent.

  • Fair rent was fixed by the Court.
  • Mr. Saboor was directed to pay rent on time.
  • In case of default of rent of two months continuously Mr. Ansar is entitled to take vacate possession of his house from Mr. Saboor.

Withdrawal of Rent Case Study

Synopsis

Mr. Shahzad gave his house on rent to Mr. Salahuddin, but Salahuddin not increase rent as decided and whenever Mr. Shahzad requested to increase rent Salahuddin promised to increase after few months but never increased and meanwhile Mr. Shahzad settled in abroad after few years the Tenant stop paying rent to the sister of Mr. Shahzad.

Problem

When the sister of Mr. Shahzad requested to vacate the house then Mr. Salahuddin informed that he is not defaulter because he was depositing rent in court for last several years.

Solution

Mr. Shahzad approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for his rent matter.

  • Mr. Shahzad withdrawn rent amount which was depositing in court through his sister.
Withdrawal of Rent
Stay from Ejectment

Stay from Ejectment Case Study

Synopsis

Mrs. Sameera is a school teacher and living in a rental house along with her three daughters but Mrs. Jameela increasing rent very high against the decided terms and conditions of Tenancy Agreement every year.

Problem

When Mrs. Sameera refused to increase rent more than 10% of present rent then Mrs. Jameela threaten to vacate the premises in one week otherwise will throw out their belongings out of the house.

Solution

Mrs. Sameera approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for her matter.

  • Mrs. Jameela cannot throw out the belongings of Mrs. Sameera without due process of law during tenancy period.
  • Mrs. Jameela directed not to increase rent more than 10% as mention in Tenancy Agreement.
  • If Mrs. Jameela wants to eject Mrs. Sameera then she has to give notice of three months.

Deposition of Rent in Court

Case Study

Synopsis

Mr. Saleem is a businessman and his office is a rental place whose owner is Mr. Ghaffar and Mr. Ghaffar by nature is a greedy person.

Problem

When the business of Mr. Saleem was going well and increasing reputation then Mr. Ghaffar started his demand to increase double rent otherwise vacate the premises.

Solution

Mr. Saleem approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for his case of deposition of rent in court.

  • Mr. Saleem started to deposit rent in court.
Deposition of Rent in Court
Succession Certificate

Succession Certificate Case Study

Synopsis

Mr. Shamim died and left behind him surviving legal heirs his wife, one son and one daughter. Ahsan was a businessman and having bank accounts in his name and one joint account with his brother Saud.

Problem

Inheritance share of sisters of Ahsan was lying in the joint account for purchase of property in the name of sisters, but unfortunately Shamim died and his brother need of a Succession Certificate to withdraw the amount from his joint account.

Solution

Mr. Saud along with the son of his brother approached and appointed Shabana Ali & Associates for their case of Succession Certificate.

  • Succession Certificate granted to the legal heirs of Shamim.
  • Legal heirs were entitled to withdraw the amount lying in his bank accounts.

If any case study is helpful to you and to your case, please contact us now.For example, if you have a tax matter such as issuance of NTN, we can assist.